NWSL awards: Record-breaking Ashley Sanchez is our MVP, but who else wins?

Awards season has arrived again for the NWSL, and choosing winners feels more difficult than ever given the variety of standout individual performances in 2026.

Someone must win, however, and we are willing to enter the endless arguments by presenting our votes in each of the league’s official awards.

Who should be the MVP? The knee-jerk follow-up: Is that the best player of the year or the most valuable to her team? Is the best coach the one who won the most, or the one who did more with less? And should the Defender of the Year be awarded on defensive merit, or should outrageous offensive output from a defensive position be rewarded?

Winners will be unveiled at the NWSL Awards show on Nov. 18 (6:30 p.m. ET, ESPN2).

Below are our choices and reasoning. And remember: In awards season, everyone is correct. Or maybe everyone is wrong.

All statistics are from ESPN Research.


Sanchez scored 20 goals this season, tying Temwa Chawinga‘s league record from 2024. Those are the only two occasions in which a player has reached 20 goals scored in a single season (the 2026 NWSL season was four games longer due to expansion). That feat, and the company Sanchez shares in achieving it, makes her entirely worthy of the MVP award.

Sanchez’s goal haul was appointment viewing as the season progressed and she kept scoring. She also achieved that remarkable output in her first season playing on the wing after moving wide from a longtime central position. She scored 20 of North Carolina’s 52 goals this season and added five assists, making her the league leader in goal contributions by four.

Yes, the Courage missed the playoffs. For some (many, perhaps, as I have had plenty of these conversations in recent weeks), that is a disqualifier from the MVP award. I rebut that this is an individual award, and Sanchez’s achievement was not merely good — it was historic.

Forward Sam Kerr also won the MVP award but missed the playoffs in 2017 (a much different league, granted), when she scored 17 goals, then a league record.

If a 20-goal output in a single season is not worthy of MVP, then what is? To be clear, I am against the idea that the Golden Boot winner should be the default MVP. But this was not the underwhelming Golden Boot race of 2021, when Ashley Hatch‘s 10 goals were enough to claim the crown. If 20 goals suddenly become the norm, we’ll all need to recalibrate how we view the accomplishment.

Granted, Sanchez has competition for this award. There is a handful of defensible alternative selections for MVP this year, some of whom are not even on the league’s official five-player short list (hello, Croix Bethune?). I am on the record on this website and on our TV airwaves from early — and midseason — that I thought Trinity Rodman was the MVP at the time.

She has proven again during these playoffs why she deserves the award, adding two goals and two assists to her 12 goals and eight assists in the regular season. Officially speaking, the playoffs don’t count toward awards voting. But they certainly underscored Rodman’s value (and boosted her chances given the timing of voting).

Still, Sanchez narrowly gets my vote for an undeniable achievement.

play

0:39

Ashley Sanchez scores Penalty Goals vs. Utah Royals

Bethune broke the single-season record with 11 assists this year as she assumed the starring role in Kansas City’s revamped midfield. Bethune is a playmaker with exquisite vision, sensational technical ability, and a killer final pass. In 2026, she put it all together for her most consistent and impactful — dare we say valuable? — season yet. She was also durable — something U.S. head coach Emma Hayes has demanded from her — as she played in 26 regular-season games and only missed a brief spell in September and October with a hip injury.

Again, the playoffs don’t officially count toward awards voting, but Bethune added another feather to her cap on Sunday with a sublime goal on a direct free kick to help Kansas City advance to this year’s final. She had my vote well before that game kicked off.

The Current struggled early in the year as they adapted to a new world with Chris Armas on the sidelines in place of Vlatko Andonovski. There were changes on the field, too, including the loss of rising star midfielder Claire Hutton, whose outgoing transfer to Bay FC happened almost simultaneously with Bethune’s arrival last offseason.

Hutton’s absence in defensive midfield loomed large until Vanessa DiBernardo returned from maternity leave in the summer. With the double pivot reestablished, Bethune thrived in a free role.

San Diego Wave FC midfielder Kenza Dali was second on my ballot. The 35-year-old French maestro is still the NWSL’s definition of a “pure footballer,” and she led the league in chances created (63). Not enough of those turned into goals (four assists from 8.40 expected assists), which is more of a Wave problem with efficiency. Bethune delivered on her 45 chances created.

play

0:42

Croix Bethune with a Spectacular Goal vs. NJ/NY Gotham FC

Defender of the Year: Kennedy Wesley, San Diego Wave FC

This award is likely to draw the most polarizing debate. Should the Defender of the Year be the player who displayed the best defensive attributes, like tackles, interceptions, recoveries, duels and all the gritty things one expects from a defender, on top of the modern demands of playing out of the back? Yes, is my answer. And that is why Wesley got my vote.

The counterpoint in the race for this award is Denver Summit FC fullback Janine Sonis, who is also a finalist for MVP. Sonis scored 12 goals and added eight assists as a fullback. For context, those are the exact numbers that Rodman put up as a winger.

Sonis also ranked fifth in the entire league in chances created, ahead of most players who are actually paid to go score goals and not prevent them. For that, Sonis is a lock on my Best XI ballot as a fullback, and I am confident when I say we might never see a season like that again from a fullback.

Denver’s defense, however, was merely average, and the Summit had an awful habit of blowing multigoal leads in their inaugural season. For that, I am viewing this Defender of the Year award through the lens of defending. Wesley received my vote for her growing defensive presence on a Wave team that had the third-best defense in the NWSL.

Wesley ranks among the league leaders in defensive interventions and particularly excels in shot blocking and clearances (fifth and sixth, respectively). She is also a solid, reliable, relatively mistake-free defender. Furthermore, she meets the demands of the modern center back by calmly playing out of pressure.

Wesley ranks fifth in the league in touches and passes completed. Neutrals around the league lauded San Diego for its attractive style of possession soccer. The Wave love to play out of pressure on the ground, and that starts in the back with Wesley.

play

1:04

Kennedy Wesley gets on the scoresheet for San Diego Wave FC

Berger had the best save percentage (76.5%) among all regular starters (anyone who played more than three games), and she consistently bailed out Gotham when the team’s attack sputtered and they needed to win tight games. They won 12 regular-season games by one goal in 2026, equaling the Orlando Pride‘s mark from 2024.

Berger kept things tight even when Gotham wasn’t clicking offensively (which cost them in the playoffs) and as the back line in front of her rotated. Emily Sonnett sustained a season-ending knee injury in July, which shook up the center of Gotham’s defense. Midge Purce rotated between fullback and winger.

The pieces in front of Berger changed and swapped roles frequently, but the shutouts kept coming. She had 11 in the regular season, one less than Washington Spirit goalkeeper Sandy MacIver.

Berger is also one of the most uniquely savvy goalkeepers in the world, the type of daring and astute player who redefines a position. One moment she is 40 yards off her line playing sweeper keeper.

The next, she’s calmly performing a cutback inside her own six-yard box as an opposing forward tries to slide tackle her. Then, she can ping a ball 50 yards to her teammate’s foot.

Berger is part elite shot-stopper, part 12th field player.

play

0:44

Ann-Katrin Berger makes a nice stop

Rookie of the Year: Mimi Van Zanten, San Diego Wave FC fullback

This one might as well be a coin flip, but the challenge comes in weighing completely different positions.

Houston Dash attacking midfielder Kat Rader was a menace this year, scoring 10 goals (one short of the rookie record) for a young Houston team that struggled. She has a bright future.

My vote, however, came down to two rookies who immediately stepped into starting roles for top-of-the-table teams: Gotham FC rookie forward Jordynn Dudley and Van Zanten in San Diego.

Van Zanten ultimately got my vote for being a shutdown fullback in a league dominated by world-class wingers. She kept players like Chawinga in her pocket this season. Van Zanten finished 17th in the NWSL in defensive interventions — and second in tackles made, behind only Seattle Reign FC defensive midfielder Sam Meza.

Like Wesley, Van Zanten was also instrumental in the Wave’s build-out play. Van Zanten started all but one game for the Wave this year (that one due to a red card suspension). That is an incredible amount of trust being placed in a rookie, and Van Zanten delivered.

Dudley was a handful for opponents, and she dished it back: She led the league in fouls drawn and fouls committed. Her four goals and three assists were a relatively modest output, but so much of her brilliance was off the ball, in combination plays, and in stretching opponents. Dudley missed the final six weeks of Gotham’s season due to a foot fracture, and Gotham sorely missed her.

play

0:37

Amelia Van Zanten scores in the 9′

Coach of the Year: Juan Carlos Amoros, Gotham FC

We are all still shaking off the cobwebs of last year’s coaching debate, and the dynamics are similar this time around. Is it more impressive that Amoros won the NWSL Shield, Jonas Eidevall and the Wave nearly won it while playing a clear style, or that Jimmy Coenraets guided the Utah Royals to a surprise semifinal appearance on a smaller budget and with fewer stars?

They all have merit, and what Coenraets did this year deserves a spotlight. The product of his work can be seen in Utah’s collective identity and in the development of so many individual players.

Amoros ultimately got my vote not just because Gotham FC won the Shield, but because they did it despite constant change. Thirty-one players saw the field for Gotham this season, more than any other NWSL team.

Plenty of that was by necessity, as Sonnett, Dudley, and Bruninha sustained season-ending injuries, and after Esther González abruptly left the team by mutual contract termination. Jaedyn Shaw and Rose Lavelle struggled through injuries in the final weeks of the season, and the team’s poor health ultimately contributed to Gotham’s underwhelming playoff campaign.

All that further underscored what an achievement it was to win the NWSL Shield. The Shield rewards consistent results, and Gotham achieved those despite hardly any consistency in its lineup. Even Amoros stepped away for five weeks in the summer for parental leave.

Most teams in the NWSL would have tanked under those circumstances. Even some of the contenders in the league are built around star players whose absences would lead to their demise. Gotham is certainly a different team with and without Lavelle, for one, and their success was hardly pretty at times. It got downright ugly in the playoffs as the year caught up to them.

Still, they only lost five of their 30 regular-season games this year despite the rotation and despite playing more games than any other NWSL team due to FIFA and Concacaf competitions.

Amoros has created a plug-and-play system where the whole is greater than the sum of its parts when needed. It has now produced five trophies over the past four seasons.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Skip to toolbar