Meet the Cast Behind Dan Levy’s Hilarious New Show Big Mistakes

Dan Levy as Nicky

big mistakes l to r jacob gutierrez as tareq and dan levy as nicky in episode 103 of big mistakes cr courtesy of netflix © 2026
Courtesy of Netflix

Dan Levy anchors the series as Nicky, a gay pastor suddenly thrown into criminal chaos. Anxious, overthinking, and deeply unqualified for a life of crime, Nicky is essentially Levy’s worst-case scenario personified.

Best known for co-creating and starring in the Emmy-winning series Schitt’s Creek, Levy returns to familiar ground here, playing a lovable, tightly wound character navigating discomfort with his signature wit.

Taylor Ortega as Morgan

big mistakes l to r dan levy as nicky and taylor ortega as morgan in episode 105 of big mistakes cr spencer pazernetflix © 2025
Courtesy of Netflix

Morgan, Nicky’s sister, sets the entire series in motion with one very bad decision. Messy, grouchy, and rough around the edges, she can’t help but drag her family into situations they are hilariously unprepared for.

Ortega first broke out through digital shorts and comedy before gaining wider recognition as a correspondent on The Daily Show. She’s appeared on shows such as Succession and Search Party, but Big Mistakes marks her first time as a series lead.

Advertisement – Continue Reading Below

Laurie Metcalf as Linda

big mistakes laurie metcalf as linda in episode 104 of big mistakes cr spencer pazernetflix © 2025
Courtesy of Netflix

Laurie Metcalf brings an entertaining maternal energy to Big Mistakes as Linda, the siblings’ mother, whose local political campaign becomes complicated by her children’s illicit activity.

Metcalf is a sitcom legend, having played unforgettable roles in Roseanne, The Conners, and The Big Bang Theory.

Boran Kuzum as Yusuf

boran kuzum as yusuf in episode 101 of big mistakes cr courtesy of netflix © 2026
Courtesy of Netflix

Boran Kuzum plays Yuzuf, the store owner whose necklace Morgan steals. After recognizing Morgan, he pulls the siblings into assisting in increasingly shady deals.

Kuzum has built his career in Turkish television and film, with Big Mistakes marking his first international series debut.

Advertisement – Continue Reading Below

Jack Innanen as Max

big mistakes jack innanen as max in episode 104 of big mistakes cr courtesy of netflix © 2026
Courtesy of Netflix

Max is Morgan’s overly eager boyfriend, already thinking about marriage long before she is. His intensity raises more questions than answers, and adds another layer of awkward tension to an already unstable situation.

Jack Innanen is known for his deadpan delivery and offbeat comedic style, with appearances in the TV shows The Sex Lives of College Girls and Overcompensating.

Abby Quinn as Natalie

big mistakes l to r elizabeth perkins as annette, taylor ortega as morgan, laurie metcalf as linda, abby quinn as natalie, and john noble barrack as kevin in episode 108 of big mistakes cr courtesy of netflix © 2025
Courtesy of Netflix

Natalie is Nicky and Morgan’s poised youngest sibling, caught between her mother’s political ambitions and her family’s unraveling situation. As she helps manage Linda’s campaign, she’s inevitably pulled in deeper to their troubles.

Abby Quinn first gained attention in Mad About You and has since carved out a niche in character-driven projects like Knock at the Cabin (2023) and Hell of a Summer (2023).

Advertisement – Continue Reading Below

Jacob Gutierrez as Tareq

big mistakes l to r jacob gutierrez as tareq and dan levy as nicky in episode 103 of big mistakes cr courtesy of netflix © 2026
Courtesy of Netflix

Tareq, Nicky’s boyfriend, is a local handyman, balancing Nicky’s public role as a pastor with their private relationship.

Big Mistakes marks Gutierrez’s shift to television, following his breakout role as the lead in Aladdin on Broadway. He told Out Magazine he landed the role through his niece, who was interning at a casting agency. She sent him the part after realizing he was a perfect fit.

Elizabeth Perkins as Annette

elizabeth perkins as annette in episode 103 of big mistakes
Courtesy of Netflix

Annette is Max’s devoted mother, deeply rooted in the community as a local real estate agent.

Elizabeth Perkins brings decades of experience to the role, with recent appearances in The Housemaid (2025), The Afterparty, Minx, and This Is Us. She is perhaps best known for her performances in the TV show Weeds, as well as films including About Last Night… (1986), Big (1988), and Miracle on 34th Street (1994).

Advertisement – Continue Reading Below

Mark Ivanir as Ivan

dan levy as nicky, taylor ortega as morgan, and mark ivanir as ivan in episode 103 of big mistakes
SPENCER PAZER

Ivan is Yusuf’s boss, whom Nicky and Morgan are eventually forced to confront.

Fluent in six languages, Mark Ivanir is a Soviet-born Israeli actor. His acting credits include Schindler’s List, Mr. & Mrs. Smith, The Good Shepherd, The Terminal, and more. More recently, he appeared as Dr. Wasserman in Emilia Pérez.

Darren Goldstein as Tom Donaldson

big mistakes l to r laurie metcalf as linda and darren goldstein as tom donaldson in episode 104 of big mistakes
SPENCER PAZER

Tom Donaldson is a prominent figure in the community and Linda’s primary opponent in the local political campaign.

Darren Goldstein is recognized for his roles in Ozark and The Affair.

Watch Next 

Advertisement – Continue Reading Below

You Might Also Like

Advertisement – Continue Reading Below

Advertisement – Continue Reading Below

Comments

Leave a Reply

Skip to toolbar