Brown Mascaras So Good They’ll Make You Ditch Black Forever

This waterproof mascara lengthens, curls, separates, adds volume, and won’t budge or smudge. The unique powdery formula starts off dry, and must be pumped a few times to expose it to oxygen to acheive the best result.

Benefits: Lengthening, volumizing, curling

Gen See rating: 4.6/5

Our expert says: “This brand deserves way more love. Their clean, cruelty free, vegan formulas are amazing, and the brown mascara is a lightweight, cool-toned shade that looks so natural. Truly the easiest everyday option.”—Lisa Aharon